The Walking Dead Season 5 Episode 8 Coda – Dawn Really Didn’t do it – Spoiler Warning!



Discount Sales and More the Walking Dead Memorabilia – CLICK HERE!


The Walking Dead Season 5 Episode 8 Coda – Dawn Really Didn't do it – Spoiler Warning!

So after watching the walking dead season 5 episode 8 Coda I wanted to do a video giving my thoughts on whether or not Dawn was the person who shot Beth.

Click here to see the making of:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XqJe…

Let me know what you guys think about this one.

Trevschan2 Youtube Channel ► http://www.youtube.com/trevschan2

TrevsChan2 Facebook Page ► https://www.facebook.com/trevschan2

TrevsChan2 Twitter ► https://twitter.com/trevschan2

TrevsChan2 Tumblr ► http://trevschan2.tumblr.com/

Trevschan2 Google+ ► https://plus.google.com/+Trevschan2/

Trevschan2 Blogger ► http://trevschan2.blogspot.ca/

The Walking Dead Season 4 Reviews ► http://tinyurl.com/ndw6y9e

Who Would Win Vs Series ► http://tinyurl.com/pwajujr

rated:

viewed:17558

source

The Walking Dead Season 5 Episode 8 Coda - Dawn Really Didn't do it - Spoiler Warning!

The Walking Dead Season 5 Episode 8 Coda - Dawn Really Didn't do it - Spoiler Warning!




So after watching the walking dead season 5 episode 8 Coda I wanted to do a video giving my thoughts on whether or not Dawn was the person who shot Beth.

Click here to see the making of:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XqJecSJYGo&list=UU0oqSNZI-2buYTm8V5912Qw

Let me know what you guys think about this one.


Trevschan2 Youtube Channel ► http://www.youtube.com/trevschan2

TrevsChan2 Facebook Page ► https://www.facebook.com/trevschan2

TrevsChan2 Twitter ► https://twitter.com/trevschan2

TrevsChan2 Tumblr ► http://trevschan2.tumblr.com/

Trevschan2 Google+ ► https://plus.google.com/+Trevschan2/

Trevschan2 Blogger ► http://trevschan2.blogspot.ca/

The Walking Dead Season 4 Reviews ► http://tinyurl.com/ndw6y9e

Who Would Win Vs Series ► http://tinyurl.com/pwajujr

24 thoughts on “The Walking Dead Season 5 Episode 8 Coda – Dawn Really Didn’t do it – Spoiler Warning!

  1. There is NO bullet hole in Dawn’s forehead. If you watch on slow motion
    frame by frame you can CLEARLY follow the blood from the exit wound and see
    it drop right on Beth’s forehead. It’s very clear the shot went from under
    her chin and out thru the top of her head.

  2. I just think this scene should have been shot differently. It’s ok if
    Gimple and the team wants to kill Beth off, but do it in a logical way.
    Beth stabbing Dawn with scissors in the chest armor just to get shot by
    accident was just…. a dumb way of having Beth go out. I understand the
    motive to extent, but…. seriously could they not think of another way to
    kill her??? Maybe everyone draws their guns when Rick refuses to give up
    Noah, or maybe have Beth stab Dawn in the THROAT and then she kills her by
    reaction and they both die? Idk it was just dumb, espcially when the
    person killing Beth didn’t even MEAN to do it!!! At least the Governor
    hacked Hershel up like 10 times to show he really meant it. Rick had to
    kill Shane in self defense because of how loopy he was. Even Bob got a
    laugh or two before he died from his walker bite. But Beth was a tragic
    death, like Romeo and Juliet killing themselves because they thought the
    other was dead when they really weren’t.

    The other funny part is that actress Emily Kinney who played Beth said in
    an interview the other day that she thought her character should have died
    differently. She thought either she should have lived to develop her more
    or kill her in a logical way.

    This whole thing makes me scratch my head over and over again. I really
    was expecting more from the hospital arch. As short as the Terminus arch
    was, it made sense and was intense. This seemed to drag out and killed a
    main character off in a cliche way.

    Oh and in terms of Dawn “not” killing Beth, she did. Beth’s head was down
    and the gun shot from bellow and killed her. That was just a dot of blood
    on her forehead from the explosion. That really shouldn’t be the thing to
    discuss in these vids, the above should be lol.

  3. +Zuri Frazier
    You say as a friend you are saying that overly aggressive comment? So what
    if he makes a few mistakes in some videos. There was no need to go full out
    being rude to Trev about his videos. You said to another comment saying
    “Explain how i am a hater”, we don’t need to explain how you are a hater,
    you did it well enough in that long, detailed comment you provided.
    To be quite honest i am with Trev on the majority of factors he brought up
    in the video. When watching the mid-season finale for the first time you
    would never consider someone else shooting Beth because of how they have
    portrayed Dawn in the first half of the season. But seriously, how the fuck
    could Dawn of possibly shot her in that way without us seeing it. From the
    angles and the point where the bullet entered, it seems quite ridiculous
    that you doubt the theory so much. Although i do understand your point
    about how the officers pulled out their guns after Daryl made a move on
    Dawn but you need to consider the way she was actually killed more, rather
    than going on a full-out rant on how Trev always does things wrong.
    As soon as Trev makes one small mistake in a video, you count the whole
    video as being wrong, that is why you are very idiotic for just posting
    such a rude comment to Trev.
    I don’t see you as any friend to Trev and i don’t think you enjoy his
    videos as much as others including myself.

    You may as well just leave the channel and do not come back. As Trev said
    in his flagger rant video, “You are not welcome”.

  4. I want to believe this but I really just can’t. For one of those female
    agents to shoot Beth doesn’t make sense. They wanted to get rid of Dawn and
    by accidentally shooting Beth when really aiming for Dawn doesn’t make
    sense either because Dawn was standing right there and the bullet would’ve
    passed her just by an inch to then fly up in Beth’s face? Nah. I don’t
    think so.
    I have watched the clip again and again and I really do believe that Dawn
    says ”I didn’t mean to” because she might’ve shot Beth in a reflex, in
    the heat of the moment. Anyway, Beth and Dawn are both dead, better accept
    it and move on.

  5. It surley was a production mistake. I mean they were all standing in a long
    floor were both groups had perfect sight of each other. I really doubt
    that; Rick, Daryl, Carol, Sasha and Tyreese wouldnt saw it when someone
    infront of them would pull their gun and shot beth. They surley would saw
    that specially Daryl Sasha Tyreese and Carol cause they needed to watch the
    people at the back of Dawn. But beth blocked the sight of dawn a little bit
    and also kinda guarded her so that rick and daryl coudlnt react in time.
    And another thing when the shoot went off, they all looked at dawn … if
    the shoot went from the other cops behind dawn, than Rick and co. would
    surley have seen it since it was at their eyesight, i mean its just a small
    floor and even when they all were looking at dawn and beth they still could
    see the others.

  6. Most likely what happened; The guy who made the effects did the best he
    could with the material he was handed The moment when Dawn pulls up the gun
    and Beth falls to the ground was not synchronized perfectly and she fell
    down before the gun was in the right position. They probably noticed that
    afterwards when editing. It was too late to go back and recast the scene so
    they rolled with it anyway, making it look as good as possible.

  7. *Trev!*
    I think I know who killed Beth! If you pause the scene where that woman
    officer that was captured (forgotten her name damn it!) says “Stop it was
    just her!. It’s over now.” the camera should pan her whole group of
    officers gun’s raised. But behind them is the Doctor (Gorman I think it
    is?) In the scene it looks like he’s either hiding something under his
    lab-coat plus he doesn’t even look emotional like everyone else that knew
    her; It’s as if he’s pulling the “OMFG I just survived!” look, and since
    he’s behind everyone else he’s have the perfect moment to do it.
    Why would he do it you ask?
    1. He might have actually tried to kill Dawn but failed.
    2. Plus Gorman wouldn’t want the group dispersing because he could have
    presumed that Beth was going to kill Dawn; even if it did happen he’d be
    completely useless on his own and would probably die sooner or taken
    advantage of again for his medical skills.
    Two he guessed that everyone in Rick’s group would die sooner because they
    are out on the roads and Beth is most likely to be killed off so he would
    be generously to give her a quick and somewhat painless death.
    I’m sorry if this turns out to be a *spoiler* type of thing but it’s just
    my theory…..

  8. Here’s my take: no one can analyze the blood splatter of a fake gunshot
    wound with any accuracy because the shot (obviously) never happened. With
    that said, TWD is normally more detail oriented. They shouldn’t have had
    Beth’s wound in the wrong place if it turns out that Dawn did, in fact,
    shoot Beth, which I think she did because of the comments of Scott Gimple.
    I really just want the Dawn story line to be over. It wasn’t necessary or
    believable in the least. 

  9. I’m glad you now believe it was Dawn. Another reason why it couldn’t have
    been the other female cop is that her wrists were still cuffed and, even if
    she had been freed, her side arm had been confiscated by the survivors.

  10. Most likely: Sloppy TV production

    If you can’t sleep at night because of this, perhaps tell yourself that
    Beth looked down instinctively at Dawn’s hand as she shot and then looked
    up… that would be one way for the bullet to enter her forehead.

    I too wanted it to all add up perfectly, but I guess we just have to accept
    it’s TV, and they have a limited amount of time to shoot it. There was a
    miscommunication between the makeup department and the camera team that’s
    all.

  11. Huh? I understand the question, but it must just be poor editing/directing,
    right? I mean anyone of the hospital shooting Beth the moment she attacks
    Dawn just doen´t make any fucking sense, does it?
    And seeing the picture, notice again, where Beth supposedly put the
    scissors! Makes total sense that she might have looked down the moment she
    stabbed, to make Dawn possibly shoot her in that angle.

  12. Did anybody else find Dawn am interesting empathetic and compelling
    character? I’m actually sad she’s gone. She was really interesting. About
    as interesting as Carol I’d say. Like imagine a female, unfit to lead but
    has to be a leader version of Rick 

  13. Beth was looking down after she stabbed Dawn. Her head went up because of
    the force of the bullet. Of course it was Dawn who shot her. None of the
    other cops had their guns drawn until Darryl shot Dawn. And if another cop
    had done it, they would have noticed. And Dawn did not say “It wasn’t me”
    she said “I didn’t mean to” It was an involuntary reaction to being
    stabbed. She regretted it immediately because she knew she would die
    because of it.
    I honestly don’t know why you keep making these videos about demonstrably
    false topics.

  14. This channel is better than The a Talking Dead I’m my opinion because well
    for one your hilarious sometimes and two because you go into so much detail
    and say things that the talking dead doesn’t even think about until they
    hear u talking about it! XD keep up the good work Trev! -Mike

  15. Trev. I think it was just a mistake in the filming, like the car dropping
    off the bridge. If it were truly another officer, they would make that
    clear.

  16. Hey Trev!
    I think it was Noah that shot Beth. If you watch the scene you can see that
    Beth leans into Dawn’s left side as she stabs her, meaning that the bullet
    could potentially have come from over Dawn’s left shoulder; where Noah was
    standing. It matches up with the trajectory of the bullet, entrance and
    exit wound etc.
    I know that Noah gave his pistol to Rick but it’s possible he had another.
    I have two theories as to why Noah may shot Beth. The first being that he
    was aiming for Dawn and somehow missed. The second that he intentionally
    shot Beth knowing that this would lead to Dawn’s death and his escape from
    the hospital (taking on the theme of the hospital and story arc that people
    use others to get what they want). We don’t really know much about Noah so
    it’s possible.
    I’m not saying this is true or anything, it’s just one of my theories.
    Excellent vid though Trev. Love your channel, keep making vids bud! You
    keep me going in these breaks between seasons/mid-seasons. ;)

  17. Trev, your own slow motion pic shows there was no entry wound on Beth’s
    forehead, before the back of her head exploded. Watch it again, you cannot
    have a blown out mess in the back of Beth’s head, without seeing the entry
    wound if it were on her forehead. The splatter shows on her forehead a
    second after.

    Also, the second female cop is shorter then me, I’m not a tall female, and
    I know my way around a gun pretty darn well, I couldn’t have put a bullet
    into Beth’s forehead where the blood splatter lands, without hitting Dawn
    first, unless I was standing on something. (I’m not trolling Trev, just
    putting up an argument for the bullet entry being under Beth’s chin, you
    know I’m a loyal fan) I think the biggest production mistake that was made,
    is that they didn’t show the right side of Beth’s face after, but I’m sure
    it would have been too gruesome for AMC.
    So, I guess what I am saying is, you took the time to draw the red line
    connecting the spatter to the exit wound, now take the time to draw a line
    from under Beth’s chin to the exit wound. If you don’t like the outcome of
    that, figure in your mind exactly how tall the person whom shot that high
    on Beth’s head, would have had to be, to not hit Dawn also.

    Let me know Trev, as always, love your channel and reviews.

Comments are closed.